BharatBenz 1617RD vs BharatBenz 1917R vs BharatBenz 1917R 5900/7400 CBC vs Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG vs Eicher Pro 3019 vs Tata Ultra 3021.S: Price & Specs Comparison
By TruckOnWheels Editorial Team · Last updated 27 Nov 2025
Tata Ultra 3021.S leads on power at 205 HP.
 BharatBenz 1617RD ₹26.30 Lakh - ₹28.40 Lakh |  BharatBenz 1917R ₹24.12 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh | BharatBenz 1917R 5900/7400 CBC ₹24.12 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh |  Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG ₹25.56 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh |  Eicher Pro 3019 ₹25.12 Lakh - ₹28.18 Lakh |  Tata Ultra 3021.S ₹27.35 Lakh - ₹28.18 Lakh | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | ₹26.30 Lakh - ₹28.40 Lakh | ₹24.12 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh | ₹24.12 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh | ₹25.56 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh | ₹25.12 Lakh - ₹28.18 Lakh | ₹27.35 Lakh - ₹28.18 Lakh |
| Body Type | Trucks | Trucks | Trucks | Trucks | Trucks | Trucks |
| Engine | 3900 cc | 3900 cc | 3900 cc | 3760 cc | 3800 cc | 5000 cc |
| Power | 125 kW | 125 kW | 125 kW | 100 kw | 134 kW | 205 hp |
| Max Torque | 520 Nm Nm | 520 Nm Nm | 520 Nm Nm | 450 Nm Nm | 600 Nm Nm | 850 Nm Nm |
| Mileage | 5.5-6.5 kmpl | 6.5 kmpl | 6.5 kmpl | 7 kmpl | 6.5 kmpl | 4 kmpl |
| Gross Vehicle Weight | 16190 kg | 18500 kg | 18500 kg | 14250 kg | 18500 kg | 30000 kg |
| Payload | 9750 Kgs | 9750 Kgs | 9750 Kgs | 7500 Kgs | 10690 Kgs | 14250 Kgs |
| No. of Tyres | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 14 |
| Fuel Type | Diesel | Diesel | Diesel | CNG | Diesel | Diesel |
| Gear Box | Improved G85, 6F+1R, Mechanical, Synchromesh Gears | Gear BoxImproved G85, 6F+1R, Mechanical, Synchromesh Gears | Improved G85, 6F+1R, Mechanical, Synchromesh Gears | ET 50S7 (7 Forward + 1 Reverse ) | ET60S7 (6 Forward + 1 Reverse) | 6 Forward + 1 Reverse |
| Chassis Type | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Day and Sleeper Cabin |
You can compare up to 6 trucks at a time.
Review
Pros & Cons
BharatBenz 1617RD
Pros
- Good fuel efficiency for operational cost savings
- Robust build quality ensures durability on tough roads
- Reliable performance reduces downtime
Cons
- Higher initial purchase price
- Spare parts can be more expensive
- Spare parts availability might be an issue in very remote regions
BharatBenz 1917R
Pros
- Good fuel economy and operational efficiency
- Robust build quality and overall durability
- Comfortable and ergonomic cabin for drivers
Cons
- Higher initial purchase price compared to some rivals
- Maintenance and spare part costs can be elevated
- AdBlue or urea fluid requirement adds to running expenses
BharatBenz 1917R 5900/7400 CBC
Pros
- Good fuel efficiency for its weight class
- Robust build quality ensures durability on challenging roads
- Comfortable cabin design reduces driver fatigue on long hauls
Cons
- Higher initial purchase price compared to some domestic alternatives
- Spare parts might be relatively more expensive than local brands
- Requires specialized expertise for complex repairs and diagnostics
Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG
Pros
- Lower running cost due to more economical CNG fuel
- Reduced exhaust emissions making it an environmentally friendly option
- Quieter engine operation compared to diesel trucks
Cons
- Limited availability of CNG refueling stations in many non metro regions
- Potentially lower power and torque output compared to equivalent diesel models
- Shorter driving range due to CNG tank capacity and less frequent stations
Eicher Pro 3019
Pros
- Impressive fuel economy for its class
- Competitive acquisition cost offering good value
- Widespread service and spare parts availability across India
Cons
- Cabin refinement might not match premium global trucks
- Noise and vibration levels could be further improved
- Limited advanced driver assistance features
Tata Ultra 3021.S
Pros
- Extensive service and spare parts network across India
- Strong build quality suitable for diverse Indian road conditions
- Generally considered fuel efficient for its class
Cons
- Higher initial purchase price compared to some segment competitors
- Cabin refinement might not match some international rivals
- Some users report occasional issues with advanced electronics
Which to buy
Which One Fits Your Use Case?
BharatBenz 1617RD
Best for:
- Construction material transport
- Intercity transport of goods
BharatBenz 1917R
Best for:
- Construction material transport
- logistics
- Intercity transport of goods
BharatBenz 1917R 5900/7400 CBC
Best for:
- Intercity transport of goods
- Logistics
- Intercity transport of goods
Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG
Best for:
- Intercity transport of goods
- logistics
- Construction material transport
Eicher Pro 3019
Best for:
- Intercity transport of goods
- Construction material transport
Tata Ultra 3021.S
Best for:
- Construction material transport
- logistics
- Intercity transport of goods
FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions
Which has better power, BharatBenz 1617RD vs BharatBenz 1917R vs BharatBenz 1917R 5900/7400 CBC vs Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG vs Eicher Pro 3019 vs Tata Ultra 3021.S?
+−
Tata Ultra 3021.S has the better power at 205 HP.
Which has better mileage, BharatBenz 1617RD vs BharatBenz 1917R vs BharatBenz 1917R 5900/7400 CBC vs Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG vs Eicher Pro 3019 vs Tata Ultra 3021.S?
+−
Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG has the better mileage at 7 km/l.
Which has better payload, BharatBenz 1617RD vs BharatBenz 1917R vs BharatBenz 1917R 5900/7400 CBC vs Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG vs Eicher Pro 3019 vs Tata Ultra 3021.S?
+−
Tata Ultra 3021.S has the better payload at 14250 kg.
What is the estimated price of the BharatBenz 1617RD truck in India?
+−
The ex-showroom price for the BharatBenz 1617RD typically ranges from ₹23.00 Lakh to ₹26.00 Lakh in India, depending on the variant and region. This makes it a competitive heavy-duty truck offering great value for commercial vehicle buyers.
What is the ex-showroom truck price in India for the BharatBenz 1917R?
+−
The ex-showroom truck price in India for the BharatBenz 1917R typically starts from around ₹25-28 lakhs, but this can vary based on specific variants and location. It's a competitive cost for a heavy-duty truck of its caliber.
What is the estimated on-road price of the Bharatbenz 1917r Cbc in India?
+−
The estimated on-road price for the Bharatbenz 1917r Cbc can vary, but typically starts from around 27-30 Lakhs, depending on the specific city and chosen options.
What is the expected truck price in India for the Eicher Pro 2110xp Plus CNG?
+−
The ex-showroom truck price in India for the Eicher Pro 2110xp Plus CNG generally starts from around INR 18-20 Lakhs, depending on the specific variant and features. This pricing makes it a competitive option in the medium-duty CNG truck segment. It offers excellent value considering its efficiency and performance.
What is the approximate on-road price of the Eicher Pro 3019 in India?
+−
The Eicher Pro 3019's on-road price typically ranges from 24 to 28 Lakhs INR, varying by state, specific variant, and RTO charges. This is an ex-showroom estimate.
What is the estimated ex-showroom price of the Tata Ultra 3021.s truck in India?
+−
The estimated ex-showroom truck price in India for the Tata Ultra 3021.s generally ranges from ₹25 Lakh to ₹30 Lakh, depending on the variant, load body, and city. This price may vary due to government policies and state taxes. It offers great value for a medium-duty truck.