BharatBenz 1617RD vs BharatBenz 1917R vs Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG vs Eicher Pro 3019 vs Eicher Pro 3019 CNG vs Tata Ultra 3021.S: Price & Specs Comparison
By TruckOnWheels Editorial Team · Last updated 18 Dec 2025
Eicher Pro 3019 CNG is the more affordable option here by about ₹18,000. Tata Ultra 3021.S leads on power at 205 HP.
 BharatBenz 1617RD ₹26.30 Lakh - ₹28.40 Lakh |  BharatBenz 1917R ₹24.12 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh |  Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG ₹25.56 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh |  Eicher Pro 3019 ₹25.12 Lakh - ₹28.18 Lakh |  Eicher Pro 3019 CNG ₹21.00 Lakh - ₹28.00 Lakh |  Tata Ultra 3021.S ₹27.35 Lakh - ₹28.18 Lakh | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | ₹26.30 Lakh - ₹28.40 Lakh | ₹24.12 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh | ₹25.56 Lakh - ₹28.30 Lakh | ₹25.12 Lakh - ₹28.18 Lakh | ₹21.00 Lakh - ₹28.00 Lakh | ₹27.35 Lakh - ₹28.18 Lakh |
| Body Type | Trucks | Trucks | Trucks | Trucks | Trucks | Trucks |
| Engine | 3900 cc | 3900 cc | 3760 cc | 3800 cc | E494 | 5000 cc |
| Power | 125 kW | 125 kW | 100 kw | 134 kW | 110 kw | 205 hp |
| Max Torque | 520 Nm Nm | 520 Nm Nm | 450 Nm Nm | 600 Nm Nm | 500 Nm Nm | 850 Nm Nm |
| Mileage | 5.5-6.5 kmpl | 6.5 kmpl | 7 kmpl | 6.5 kmpl | 8 kmpl | 4 kmpl |
| Gross Vehicle Weight | 16190 kg | 18500 kg | 14250 kg | 18500 kg | 18500 kg | 30000 kg |
| Payload | 9750 Kgs | 9750 Kgs | 7500 Kgs | 10690 Kgs | 11000 Kgs | 14250 Kgs |
| No. of Tyres | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 14 |
| Fuel Type | Diesel | Diesel | CNG | Diesel | CNG | Diesel |
| Gear Box | Improved G85, 6F+1R, Mechanical, Synchromesh Gears | Gear BoxImproved G85, 6F+1R, Mechanical, Synchromesh Gears | ET 50S7 (7 Forward + 1 Reverse ) | ET60S7 (6 Forward + 1 Reverse) | ET60S6( 6 Forward + 1 Reverse ) | 6 Forward + 1 Reverse |
| Chassis Type | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Day and Sleeper Cabin |
You can compare up to 6 trucks at a time.
Review
Pros & Cons
BharatBenz 1617RD
Pros
- Good fuel efficiency for operational cost savings
- Robust build quality ensures durability on tough roads
- Reliable performance reduces downtime
Cons
- Higher initial purchase price
- Spare parts can be more expensive
- Spare parts availability might be an issue in very remote regions
BharatBenz 1917R
Pros
- Good fuel economy and operational efficiency
- Robust build quality and overall durability
- Comfortable and ergonomic cabin for drivers
Cons
- Higher initial purchase price compared to some rivals
- Maintenance and spare part costs can be elevated
- AdBlue or urea fluid requirement adds to running expenses
Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG
Pros
- Lower running cost due to more economical CNG fuel
- Reduced exhaust emissions making it an environmentally friendly option
- Quieter engine operation compared to diesel trucks
Cons
- Limited availability of CNG refueling stations in many non metro regions
- Potentially lower power and torque output compared to equivalent diesel models
- Shorter driving range due to CNG tank capacity and less frequent stations
Eicher Pro 3019
Pros
- Impressive fuel economy for its class
- Competitive acquisition cost offering good value
- Widespread service and spare parts availability across India
Cons
- Cabin refinement might not match premium global trucks
- Noise and vibration levels could be further improved
- Limited advanced driver assistance features
Eicher Pro 3019 CNG
Pros
- The Eicher Pro 3019 Cng offers significantly lower running costs per kilometer compared to its diesel counterparts, making it an exceptionally economical choice for fleet owners operating on fixed routes or within city limits with adequate CNG infrastructure.
- As a cleaner fuel option, the Eicher Pro 3019 Cng produces substantially fewer pollutants and particulate matter, aligning with stringent environmental regulations and facilitating access to 'green zones' in major urban centers.
- Equipped with Eicher's advanced Eutech technology and a driver-friendly cabin featuring tilt/telescopic steering, this truck ensures enhanced comfort and reduced fatigue, ultimately boosting productivity for long-haul and demanding operations.
Cons
- A major limitation for the Eicher Pro 3019 Cng is the still-developing CNG filling station network, particularly on longer inter-city routes, which necessitates meticulous route planning and can restrict the truck's operational flexibility compared to diesel variants.
- While offering long-term fuel savings, the Eicher Pro 3019 Cng typically has a higher initial acquisition cost compared to a comparably spec'd diesel truck, requiring a longer payback period for the investment.
- The space occupied by CNG cylinders and their inherent weight can lead to a slightly reduced effective payload capacity and a more limited operational range before needing a refill when compared to diesel trucks of similar Gross Vehicle Weight.
Tata Ultra 3021.S
Pros
- Extensive service and spare parts network across India
- Strong build quality suitable for diverse Indian road conditions
- Generally considered fuel efficient for its class
Cons
- Higher initial purchase price compared to some segment competitors
- Cabin refinement might not match some international rivals
- Some users report occasional issues with advanced electronics
Which to buy
Which One Fits Your Use Case?
BharatBenz 1617RD
Best for:
- Construction material transport
- Intercity transport of goods
BharatBenz 1917R
Best for:
- Construction material transport
- logistics
- Intercity transport of goods
Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG
Best for:
- Intercity transport of goods
- logistics
- Construction material transport
Eicher Pro 3019
Best for:
- Intercity transport of goods
- Construction material transport
Eicher Pro 3019 CNG
Best for:
- Construction material transport
- Intercity transport of goods
Tata Ultra 3021.S
Best for:
- Construction material transport
- logistics
- Intercity transport of goods
FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheaper, BharatBenz 1617RD vs BharatBenz 1917R vs Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG vs Eicher Pro 3019 vs Eicher Pro 3019 CNG vs Tata Ultra 3021.S?
+−
Eicher Pro 3019 CNG has the lower price among these options.
Which has better power, BharatBenz 1617RD vs BharatBenz 1917R vs Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG vs Eicher Pro 3019 vs Eicher Pro 3019 CNG vs Tata Ultra 3021.S?
+−
Tata Ultra 3021.S has the better power at 205 HP.
Which has better mileage, BharatBenz 1617RD vs BharatBenz 1917R vs Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG vs Eicher Pro 3019 vs Eicher Pro 3019 CNG vs Tata Ultra 3021.S?
+−
Eicher Pro 3019 CNG has the better mileage at 8 km/l.
Which has better payload, BharatBenz 1617RD vs BharatBenz 1917R vs Eicher Pro 2110XP Plus CNG vs Eicher Pro 3019 vs Eicher Pro 3019 CNG vs Tata Ultra 3021.S?
+−
Tata Ultra 3021.S has the better payload at 14250 kg.
What is the estimated price of the BharatBenz 1617RD truck in India?
+−
The ex-showroom price for the BharatBenz 1617RD typically ranges from ₹23.00 Lakh to ₹26.00 Lakh in India, depending on the variant and region. This makes it a competitive heavy-duty truck offering great value for commercial vehicle buyers.
What is the ex-showroom truck price in India for the BharatBenz 1917R?
+−
The ex-showroom truck price in India for the BharatBenz 1917R typically starts from around ₹25-28 lakhs, but this can vary based on specific variants and location. It's a competitive cost for a heavy-duty truck of its caliber.
What is the expected truck price in India for the Eicher Pro 2110xp Plus CNG?
+−
The ex-showroom truck price in India for the Eicher Pro 2110xp Plus CNG generally starts from around INR 18-20 Lakhs, depending on the specific variant and features. This pricing makes it a competitive option in the medium-duty CNG truck segment. It offers excellent value considering its efficiency and performance.
What is the approximate on-road price of the Eicher Pro 3019 in India?
+−
The Eicher Pro 3019's on-road price typically ranges from 24 to 28 Lakhs INR, varying by state, specific variant, and RTO charges. This is an ex-showroom estimate.
What is the approximate Eicher Pro 3019 Cng price in India?
+−
The approximate ex-showroom Eicher Pro 3019 Cng price in India typically starts from around ₹29.5 Lakhs to ₹32.5 Lakhs. Final pricing can vary based on configuration, wheelbase, and applicable government taxes and subsidies.
What is the estimated ex-showroom price of the Tata Ultra 3021.s truck in India?
+−
The estimated ex-showroom truck price in India for the Tata Ultra 3021.s generally ranges from ₹25 Lakh to ₹30 Lakh, depending on the variant, load body, and city. This price may vary due to government policies and state taxes. It offers great value for a medium-duty truck.