Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo vs Tata Magic EV vs Tata Magic EV 10 Seater/2100/Electric vs Tata Magic Express Bi Fuel vs Tata Magic Mantra vs Tata Magic Mantra Bi Fuel: Price & Specs Comparison
By TruckOnWheels Editorial Team · Last updated 30 Dec 2025
Tata Magic EV 10 Seater/2100/Electric leads on payload at 2180 kg.
 Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo ₹5.39 Lakh - ₹6.60 Lakh |  Tata Magic EV ₹5.10 Lakh |  Tata Magic EV 10 Seater/2100/Electric ₹5.10 Lakh |  Tata Magic Express Bi Fuel ₹7.62 Lakh |  Tata Magic Mantra ₹7.30 Lakh |  Tata Magic Mantra Bi Fuel ₹7.62 Lakh | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | ₹5.39 Lakh - ₹6.60 Lakh | ₹5.10 Lakh | ₹5.10 Lakh | ₹7.62 Lakh | ₹7.30 Lakh | ₹7.62 Lakh |
| Body Type | 4 Wheeler | 4 Wheeler | 4 Wheeler | 4 Wheeler | 4 Wheeler | 4 Wheeler |
| Engine | 1197 cc | NA | NA | 694 | 694 | 694 |
| Power | 60.5 kW | 26-31 kW | 26-31 kW | 25 Hp | 22.1 kW | 25 Hp |
| Max Torque | 105.5 Nm Nm | 90 Nm Nm | 90 Nm Nm | 49 Nm Nm | 55 Nm Nm | 49 Nm Nm |
| Mileage | 16.56 kmpl | 100-140 | 100-140 | 27.2 kmpl | 21.84 kmpl | 27.2 kmpl |
| Gross Vehicle Weight | 1540 kg | 2180 kg | 825 kg | 1935 kg | 1760 kg | 1875 kg |
| Payload | 920 Kgs | 825 | 2180 | 750 | NA | 750 |
| No. of Tyres | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 |
| Fuel Type | CNG+Petrol | Electric | Electric | CNG | Petrol | CNG |
| Gear Box | 5 Forward + 1 Reverse | 1 Forward + 1 Reverse | 1 Forward + 1 Reverse | GBS 65/6.31, Synchromesh on all forward gears, Sliding mesh for reverse gear | GBS 65-5/6.31, 5 Forward + 1 Reverse | GBS 65/6.31, Synchromesh on all forward gears, Sliding mesh for reverse gear |
| Chassis Type | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin |
You can compare up to 6 trucks at a time.
Review
Pros & Cons
Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo
Pros
- The Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo, especially its CNG variant, offers highly economical running costs with an impressive ARAI-certified mileage of approximately 20.88 km/kg, making it a cost-effective choice for frequent intra-city deliveries.
- Business owners highly value the legendary Maruti Suzuki reliability and its unparalleled, widespread service network across India, ensuring minimal vehicle downtime and easy availability of affordable spare parts for the Eeco Cargo.
- Its compact dimensions coupled with a tight turning radius make the Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo exceptionally easy to maneuver through congested urban streets and narrow lanes, which is ideal for last-mile delivery operations in crowded areas.
Cons
- The Eeco Cargo features a very utilitarian and basic cabin design, severely lacking modern comfort and convenience features like power windows, adjustable steering, or a proper infotainment system, which can be tiring for drivers on longer routes.
- Safety is a significant concern as the Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo comes equipped with only basic safety features such as a driver-side airbag and ABS, falling considerably short of modern active and passive safety expectations for commercial vehicles.
- While adequate for city driving, the 1.2L petrol/CNG engine of the Eeco Cargo feels noticeably underpowered and strained with a full load on highways or steep inclines, limiting its suitability for inter-city long-haul operations or challenging terrains.
Tata Magic EV
Pros
- Strong brand recognition and trust from Tata in India
- Clearly communicates its electric vehicle nature with EV
- Magic suggests innovation or a pleasant and easy experience
Cons
- Magic may sound less serious or rugged for a commercial vehicle
- Could set unrealistic expectations for the vehicle's capabilities due to Magic
- The term Magic might be perceived as whimsical or childish by some commercial buyers
Tata Magic EV 10 Seater/2100/Electric
Pros
- Zero tailpipe emissions contributing to cleaner air quality.
- Lower running costs due to cheaper electricity compared to fossil fuels.
- Quiet operation enhancing passenger comfort and reducing noise pollution.
Cons
- Limited driving range compared to conventional fuel vehicles, leading to range anxiety.
- Reliance on available charging infrastructure, which can be sparse in some regions.
- Longer charging times required compared to quick refueling of petrol or diesel vehicles.
Tata Magic Express Bi Fuel
Pros
- Offers fuel flexibility and potentially lower operating expenses due to bi-fuel capability.
- Benefits from the established reputation and extensive service network of the Tata brand.
- The term Express suggests efficiency and speed in transport operations.
Cons
- The name is quite long and might be difficult for quick recall or branding.
- The word Magic could be perceived as less serious or professional for a commercial vehicle.
- Bi-fuel systems can sometimes lead to higher initial purchase costs and slightly more complex maintenance.
Tata Magic Mantra
Pros
- Accessible initial purchase price for small businesses
- Economical to operate due to good fuel efficiency
- Spare parts are readily available across the country
Cons
- Engine performance can be modest for heavier loads or inclines
- Interior amenities and comfort features are quite basic
- Not designed for long haul transportation or highway cruising
Tata Magic Mantra Bi Fuel
Pros
- Offers significant fuel cost savings when running on compressed natural gas
- Provides fuel flexibility allowing switching between petrol and CNG based on availability
- Benefits from Tata's extensive service and spare parts network across India
Cons
- May experience a slight drop in power and torque when running on CNG
- Limited driving range on a single full tank of CNG requiring more frequent refueling
- Availability of CNG refueling stations can be a challenge in some regions
Which to buy
Which One Fits Your Use Case?
FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions
Which has better power, Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo vs Tata Magic EV vs Tata Magic EV 10 Seater/2100/Electric vs Tata Magic Express Bi Fuel vs Tata Magic Mantra vs Tata Magic Mantra Bi Fuel?
+−
Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo has the better power at 60.5 HP.
Which has better payload, Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo vs Tata Magic EV vs Tata Magic EV 10 Seater/2100/Electric vs Tata Magic Express Bi Fuel vs Tata Magic Mantra vs Tata Magic Mantra Bi Fuel?
+−
Tata Magic EV 10 Seater/2100/Electric has the better payload at 2180 kg.
What is the ex-showroom price of the Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo?
+−
The ex-showroom price for the Maruti Suzuki Eeco Cargo petrol variant starts from approximately ₹ 5.42 Lakhs. The CNG variant has an ex-showroom price starting from around ₹ 6.31 Lakhs, though prices may vary slightly by region.
What is the approximate on-road price of the Tata Magic Ev in India?
+−
The on-road price of the Tata Magic Ev varies by state, but typically starts from around INR 5.5 lakh to INR 6.5 lakh.
What is the ex-showroom price of the Tata Magic EV 10-seater in India?
+−
The ex-showroom price varies by state due to differing taxes and subsidies. It is advisable to check with local dealerships for precise, up-to-date figures.
What is the approximate on-road price of the Tata Magic Express Bi Fuel in India?
+−
The on-road price typically ranges from INR 7.5 to 8.5 lakhs, varying by city, RTO charges, and insurance costs, so it is advisable to check locally.
What is the approximate ex-showroom and on-road price range for the Tata Magic Mantra?
+−
The ex-showroom price typically starts around Rs. 5.5 - 6.0 Lakhs. The on-road price, including taxes and registration, can range from Rs. 6.0 - 6.8 Lakhs, varying by state.
What is the approximate on-road price of the Tata Magic Mantra Bi Fuel in India?
+−
The on-road price varies by city and state due to taxes and registration, but it's positioned as an affordable entry into commercial vehicle ownership in its segment.